"Value Stocks and the Macro Cycle", MSCI Research Insight, January 2011
Topic: Investing (Investment Management), Risk Management |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
Value investing is a common investment strategy, but like all other strategies it has suffered during certain periods, such as the tech rally in the late nineties. This paper examines the Value cycle globally, as well as specifically for Asia Pacific, and considers the impact of possible drivers, including those involving the overall stock market and macroeconomic factors. It was found that the Value cycle was closely linked with the level of risk aversion and, among macroeconomic variables, was most associated with the interest rate cycle.
Publication: MSCI Research Insight
Authors: OWYONG David
"Micro Caps - A Distinct Segment", MSCI Research Bulletin, January 2011
Topic: Asset Allocation and Asset Liability Management, Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
A few large asset owners have expressed a preference for an expanded opportunity set that goes beyond the traditional equity universe comprised of large, mid, and small capitalization companies. These investors have typically focused on the domestic equity market. In order to address these needs, MSCI recently launched the MSCI All Cap Indices, which aim to provide comprehensive yet accessible coverage of all capitalization segments. The MSCI All Cap Indices include micro cap securities across 24 Developed Markets and complement the existing MSCI Investable Market Indices (IMI), which cover large, mid and small cap companies.
The universe of micro cap securities represents a dynamic and evolving segment of the global equity landscape. Although micro cap securities may be perceived as more risky compared to their large cap counterparts, they have differentiated performance characteristics from other size segments and may provide an opportunity for portfolio diversification. The inclusion of the micro cap segment within MSCI All Cap Indices nearly doubles the investment opportunity set for investors and can help to address the evolving needs of global investors. This research bulletin presents the distinct characteristics of the micro cap segment and contrasts it with the investable market (IMI) segments.
Publication: MSCI Research Bulletin
Authors: MSCI Applied Research
"Update on MSCI Equal Weighted Indices", Update on MSCI Equal Weighted Indices, December 2010
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
Some investors argue that the risk of a market capitalization weighted benchmark is not limited to volatility, but also includes other dimensions, such as high concentration, and excess volatility due to pricing inefficiency. Removing the influence of prices from index weighting schemes could address the issues associated with capitalization weighted benchmarks. Historically, equal weighting has been one such approach.
The MSCI Equal Weighted Indices offer an alternative to market capitalization weighted indices. In the MSCI Equal Weighted Indices, each security is weighted equally at the quarterly index rebalancing. Weights may fluctuate between rebalancings based on the performance of each security. This alternative weighting methodology removes the influence of prices from the market capitalization weighting scheme at each index rebalancing. Equal weighted portfolios may provide a potential way for earning the small cap premium and avoiding the “bubble traps” or pricing inefficiencies in security prices.
Publication: Update on MSCI Equal Weighted Indices
Authors: MSCI Applied Research
"The Third Quarter Ends with a Blast", MSCI Researh Bulletin, October 2010
Topic: Investing (Investment Management), Risk Management |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
The US equity markets showed their strongest gains for any September on record in the 40-year history of the MSCI USA Index. Here, we highlight a few main observations through the lens of the Barra US Equity Model:
• The Growth story was really a Technology story
• The Small Cap story was partially a real small cap effect, but in fact had an important Volatility story behind it (i.e., small caps benefited from being high beta and high volatility)
• Certain sectors, like Health Care and Financial, benefited indexes across the board
Publication: MSCI Research Bulletin
Authors: MSCI Applied Research
"AH Premium and Short Sale Constraints", MSCI Research Bulletin, October 2010
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
This year, the government of China approved the launch of index futures, margin trading, and short selling of stocks. The trial program for short selling rolled out with 90 stocks in the program as of March 31, 2010. In this paper, we explore the effect of the relaxation of short sale constraints on AH premium (the price differential between the domestic listed A-shares and the Hong Kong listed H-shares). We examine the AH premium movements of the group of dual-listed Chinese shares that are permitted to short, versus the group not permitted to short, both before and after the launch of the new short selling program.
We found that the two groups of stocks traded on a different AH premium range and exhibited drastically different risk characteristics. Further analysis of the correlation of AH premium of the two groups with shorting demand in the China A-share market suggests that the relaxation of short sale constraints could potentially be playing a role in lowering AH premium.
Publication: MSCI Research Bulletin
Authors: MSCI Barra Applied Research
"The "New Classic" Equity Allocation?", MSCI Research Insight, October 2010
Topic: Asset Allocation and Asset Liability Management, Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
The recent financial crisis led many institutional investors to review their asset allocation policies and explore alternative approaches to implementation. MSCI recently held discussions around the world with major pension plans, asset managers, and investment consultants to understand different approaches to implementing equity allocation. Following these consultations, we provide a framework for the implementation of global equity allocation. Our research suggest that global equity mandates, together with dedicated emerging market mandates and small cap mandates, may be emerging as the "new classic" structure for implementing equity allocation.
Publication: MSCI Research Insight
Authors: Fachinotti Giacomo, KANG Xiaowei, NIELSEN Frank
"Stress Testing in the Investment Process", Research Insight, August 2010
Topic: Investing (Investment Management), Portfolio Construction and Optimization, Risk Management |
Asset Class: Multi-Asset Class
| Show/Hide Details >>
This paper presents a framework for conducting effective stress tests and incorporating insights from stress tests in portfolio construction. We examine how to determine the scope of the test, how to construct severe, but plausible scenarios, how to transmit the shock to the portfolio and how to incorporate the results of stress tests in portfolio construction. Stress testing can be a useful complement to risk model outputs, such as volatility, VaR, and expected shortfall. The key advantage of stress tests is that the loss is linked to a specific event, which can be more meaningful to portfolio managers than a summary statistic of a loss distribution. Prior research on stress testing has concentrated on ways to develop realistic and relevant shocks. The framework presented here attempts to expand on this, by illustrating that stress testing is a broader process addressing a wide range of investment problems and is useful in all stages of investment decisions.
Publication: Research Insight
Authors: MELAS Dimitris, RUBAN Oleg
"Revisiting Global Small Cap", Research Insight, July 2010
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
The small cap as a source of equity risk premia has been well documented in finance literature. Although small-cap stocks are often perceived as risky relative to their large-cap counterparts, they have other characteristics that may provide an opportunity for portfolio diversification and return enhancement. In particular, moving beyond the universe of large- and mid-cap stocks into the small-cap segment triples the opportunity set in terms of number of stocks available for investors. Also, there have been pronounced performance disparities between the large- and mid-cap segments and small-cap segments of equity markets. This has motivated institutional investors to seek broader exposure and to make strategic portfolio allocations to small-cap stocks, which is evident from the growth in initial funding to small cap mandates. This research insight presents the characteristics of global, small-cap stocks relative to large- and mid-cap stocks, reviews the role that global small-cap stocks can play for portfolio diversification and return enhancement and examines different investment processes to capture the small-cap premium by comparing active versus passive strategies.
Publication: Research Insight
Authors: Aylur Subramanian Raman, KILBERT Marc
"Evaluating Stock Screens with Performance Attribution", MSCI Research Bulletin, June 2010
Topic: Investing (Investment Management), Performance Analysis |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
Stock picking often is carried out with stock screens that reduce the set of eligible stocks. Such screens usually are assessed through the level and volatility of the resultant returns, mostly with associated statistics such as information ratio or Sharpe ratio. This evaluation, however, often is insufficient to uncover unintended bets, and this research bulletin suggests complementing this evaluation by conducting Barra performance attribution on the portfolios obtained from such screening strategies. For example, performance attribution indicates that the book-to-price screen performed relatively poorly in Australia because of an unintended tilt toward low-momentum stocks. In Japan, performance attribution shows that the superior performance of book-to-price over dividend yield as a selection screen from 2009 onward was largely due to non-value tilts.
Publication: MSCI Research Bulletin
Authors: MSCI Barra Applied Research
"The Curse of Olympian Spending with International Borrowing", MSCI Research Insight, June 2010
Topic: Investing (Investment Management), Risk Management |
Asset Class: Fixed Income
| Show/Hide Details >>
This Research Insight examines the impact of the unfolding European sovereign debt crisis, focusing on Greece, Portugal, Ireland, Spain, and Italy (GPISI). We use the new, short-horizon Barra Integrated Model (BIM Daily) to measure sovereign bond investment risk and provide insight into this market development. First, we highlight the background of this emerging crisis, in particular the links to government debt, fiscal deficits, maturity distribution, and levels of external borrowing. Then, we show how the recent volatility in European sovereign debt markets was reflected in BIM risk forecasts and led to high risk concentrations in a European government bond portfolio. Finally, we provide an historical and qualitative perspective to evaluate the potential widening of credit contagion.
Publication: MSCI Research Insight
Authors: ANAND Iyer, RUBAN Oleg, VANNEREM Philippe
"Is There a Link Between GDP Growth and Equity Returns?", MSCI Barra Research Bulletin, May 2010
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
The analysis of a possible positive relationship between economic growth and stock market returns is interesting both theoretically and practically. Investors often wonder if they should assign higher weight to countries with higher economic performance, hoping that economic growth will eventually show up in equity returns. Although this relationship seems quite intuitive, historically long-run stock price growth has fallen short of GDP growth in many countries. In this bulletin, we use long-term equity data to analyze the steps leading from GDP to stock prices, and point out several factors that could explain why GDP growth is diluted before it can reach shareholders.
Publication: MSCI Barra Research Bulletin
Authors: MSCI Barra Applied Research , NAGY Zoltan
"The Perils of Parity", MSCI Barra Research Insight, May 2010
Topic: Asset Allocation and Asset Liability Management, Investing (Investment Management), Portfolio Construction and Optimization, Risk Management |
Asset Class: Multi-Asset Class
| Show/Hide Details >>
This paper examines the recent trend of adding leverage to fixed income allocations of multi-asset class portfolios of large asset owners. We show that the optimality of adding leverage from a volatility-reduction perspective depends on the correlations between bonds and equities, the relative volatility of bonds versus equities, and the weights of the two asset classes in the portfolio. If correlations between bonds and equities are negative, adding leverage could reduce the volatility of a portfolio, especially if the weight in fixed income assets is low, leverage is moderate, and bonds have a low risk relative to equities. Negative correlations also increase the likelihood that adding leverage will improve the risk-return profile of the portfolio. Asset owners considering adding leverage to their fixed income allocation can examine these influences to decide whether negative correlations between bonds and equities, a low ratio of bond to equity volatility, and higher risk-adjusted returns of bonds relative to equities are likely to persist.
Publication: MSCI Barra Research Insight
Authors: MELAS Dimitris, RUBAN Oleg
"Momentum in Asia Pacific Stock Markets", MSCI Barra Research Bulletin, May 2010
Topic: Investing (Investment Management), Risk Management |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
This Research Bulletin considers Momentum in Asia Pacific stock markets. We find that Momentum has performed better in some markets than others, and its effectiveness varies across time. We use the new Barra Asia Pacific Equity Model to capture these variations across markets and over time. In addition, we test a Momentum timing strategy based on hedging exposure to Momentum during market crashes. The filter we apply, which is based on those months in which the Momentum factor was negative and statistically important, mitigates drawdowns from Momentum significantly at the regional level.
Publication: MSCI Barra Research Bulletin
Authors: MSCI Barra Applied Research , OWYONG David
"Sovereign Stress and Economic Growth: Scenarios for US Investors", MSCI Barra Research Bulletin, May 2010
Topic: Asset Allocation and Asset Liability Management, Investing (Investment Management), Risk Management |
Asset Class: Multi-Asset Class
| Show/Hide Details >>
This research bulletin is the first in a series covering various aspects of stress testing and scenario analysis. In this paper, we compare and contrast two historical scenarios that may be of current interest given the increasing uncertainty regarding the returns on sovereign fixed income investments. The scenarios we consider here are the 1998 Russian debt crisis and the 1994 US rate hike that followed the savings and loan (S&L) crisis. We put a stylized US pension plan through the stress tests using BarraOne, a risk platform that provides more than 60 preloaded historical scenarios from the 1970s to the present. Each scenario that we consider applies shocks to global market factors for equities, interest rates, credit spreads, FX rates, and commodities. We review the effect of the scenarios on the pension plan, and we discuss possible hedges.
Publication: MSCI Barra Research Bulletin
Authors: BRIAND Remy, MSCI Barra Applied Research , VANNEREM Philippe
"Assessing Interest Rate Risk Beyond Duration - Shift, Twist, Butterfly", MSCI Barra Research Insight, April 2010
Topic: Asset Allocation and Asset Liability Management, Investing (Investment Management), Risk Management |
Asset Class: Fixed Income
| Show/Hide Details >>
High fiscal deficits, a sharp rise in the issuance of sovereign debt from major developed economies, rising inflation expectations, and possible changes in central bank rates could cause the yield curves from around the world to change significantly. This poses challenges for fixed income professionals who need to address possible non-parallel changes to the term structure. This paper illustrates the capabilities of Shift-Twist-Butterfly (STB) factor models to help address these challenges. We provide a longer-term perspective on term structure changes in the Euro zone, US and Japan. Through four portfolio case studies, we show that the use of risk measures, such as duration, convexity or key rate durations, has limitations. These can be overcome by the complementary use of advanced fixed income risk models based on STB interest rate risk factors.
Publication: MSCI Barra Research Insight
Authors: ANAND Iyer, VANNEREM Philippe
"Portfolio Insights for a Deep Value Manager", MSCI Barra Research Bulletin, March 2010
Topic: Investing (Investment Management), Risk Management |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
This bulletin is the first in a series aimed at asset managers with fundamental processes. Here, we look at the momentum characteristics of deep value managers and highlight the importance of monitoring momentum tilts at the portfolio level. Value investing has been around for years and it is one of the most common investment themes around the world. Although this paper uses US based value managers for illustration, the concepts should appeal broadly to value managers around the globe.
Publication: MSCI Barra Research Bulletin
Authors: BANERJEE Arnab, BENDER Jennifer
"Risk and Style Characteristics of Chinese Funds", MSCI Barra Research Insight, March 2010
Topic: Investing (Investment Management), Risk Management |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
This paper examines the holdings data of various active funds in China to analyze their risk and style characteristics over the last five years. We show that fund managers were quick to increase their equity exposure at the beginning of the bull market, and they started to cut their equity exposure before the 2007-2008 bear market arrived. In terms of style, we find that funds had tilts toward momentum and small caps, but away from value.
Publication: MSCI Barra Research Insight
Authors: OWYONG David
"Risk Characteristics of Emerging Market Bonds", MSCI Barra Research Insights, March 2010
Topic: Investing (Investment Management), Risk Management |
Asset Class: Fixed Income, Multi-Asset Class
| Show/Hide Details >>
In 2009, emerging market bonds were among the top-performing assets in comparison to both global equity and fixed income. The recent, rapid rise in US Treasury yields and the concern over tightening monetary policies in certain countries led us to evaluate the relationship between global interest rate risks and emerging market bonds. We look at the risk characteristics of the market, along with the historical relationship of emerging market bonds with US Treasuries, other developed market sovereign bonds, and equity market volatility. We consider possible warning signals of impending volatility in emerging market bonds during the period we observed, as well as possible ways to have improved the diversification benefits with equities.
Publication: MSCI Barra Research Insights
Authors: ANAND Iyer, OWYONG David
"What Drives Long-Term Equity Returns", MSCI Barra Research Bulletin, January 2010
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
We analyze components of long run returns of international equity markets using historical data spanning the 1975-2009 period. The analysis shows that after inflation, dividend income was the most important part of equity returns for the majority of markets. Growth in real book value had a low, but steady contribution to performance. Changes in valuation tended to smooth out in the long run, but had important implications to equity investing in the short run. We also show how expectations of future excess returns – as derived from the price to book ratio – have evolved over time and converged among different regions.
Publication: MSCI Barra Research Bulletin
Authors: NAGY Zoltan
"An Update on Emerging Markets", MSCI Barra Research Insight, September 2009
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
The 2008 crisis has offered another look at how emerging market stocks have behaved relative to developed markets. In the aftermath of the crisis, we take a fresh look at emerging markets to explore these questions: Have emerging markets matched growth forecasts? Which segments have performed well? How have emerging markets behaved relative to developed markets? While in the aggregate, emerging market stocks were not immune to the crisis, there were some clear differences between emerging and developed markets in the performance of particular sectors and styles.
Publication: MSCI Barra Research Insight
Authors: BENDER Jennifer, NIELSEN Frank, Subramanian Madhusudan
"Liquidity", MSCI Barra Research Bulletin, July 2009
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
The Liquidity style factor in the new and enhanced Barra Europe Equity Model (EUE3) helps to assess the systematic risk associated with infrequent trading. In this Research Bulletin we look at the risk and return to the EUE3 Liquidity factor in different market environments, the link between stock liquidity and stock size and sector, and the relationship between the significance of the Liquidity factor and market performance. This factor's return varied with the market cycle during the rally of 1995-2000 and the correction of 2000-2003. In the more recent cycle, there was less dispersion between the rally and the correction. We also find that there are some systematic relationships between a company's liquidity and its size and sector. Finally, we find that the EUE3 Liquidity factor return tends to be statistically significant when the market moves up or down in a meaningful way, which is consistent with our analysis of the Liquidity factor in GEM2.
Publication: MSCI Barra Research Bulletins
Authors: MSCI Barra Applied Research
"International Diversification from a UK Perspective", MSCI Barra Research Insight, April 2009
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
The market turmoil of 2008 highlighted the importance of risk management to investors in the UK and worldwide. Realized risk levels and risk forecasts from the Barra Europe Equity Model (EUE2L) are both currently at the highest level for the last two decades. We explore the historical diversification effects of an international allocation for UK investors. We illustrate that investing only in the UK market can be considered an active deviation from a global benchmark. A UK domestic strategy has high concentration, leading to high asset-specific risk, and significant style and industry tilts. We show that an international allocation resulted in higher returns and lower risk for a UK investor in the last one, three, five, and ten years. In GBP terms, the MSCI All Country World Investable Market Index (ACWI IMI) a global index that could be viewed as a proxy for a global portfolio achieved higher return and lower risk compared to the MSCI UK Index during these periods. The decreases in risk represented by allocations to MSCI ACWI IMI were robust based on four different measures of portfolio risk.
Publication: MSCI Barra Research Insights
Authors: MELAS Dimitris, RUBAN Oleg
"Currency Hedging: A Free Lunch?", MSCI Barra Research Insight, April 2009
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Currencies
| Show/Hide Details >>
This Research Insight examines the question of whether currency hedging is a free lunch' of risk reduction and zero expected returns. Using a long history of hedged and unhedged MSCI indices, we find that hedging does not always reduce risk, nor are mean returns zero. Contrary to some prior studies, we find there is no free lunch for the equity investor. Instead, we conclude that the usual, intuitive relationships hold: less risk usually means lower returns, and more risk, higher returns. Our research indicates that whether hedging pays off depends not only on the base currency, market, and hedging horizon, but also on the investor's goals of risk reduction or return/risk maximization.
Publication: MSCI Barra Research Insights
Authors: CHANG Kelly
"Currency Hedging", MSCI Barra Research Bulletin, February 2009
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
We investigate the question of whether currency hedging pays off in the long run using data from the hedged and unhedged versions of the MSCI Global Investable Market Indices. These data allow us to perform comparisons of unusually large breadth (4 base currencies and 40 markets) and history (1987 to 2008). Our research indicates that the answer depends not only on the base currency, market, and hedging horizon, but also on the investor's goals, e.g. risk reduction or return/risk maximization.
Publication: MSCI Barra Research Bulletins
Authors: MSCI Barra Applied Research
"Black October: A Market Update", MSCI Barra Research Bulletin, November 2008
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
Although the equity markets in October 2008 generated seemingly grim news day after day, how bad were they really? In this Research Bulletin, we examine the returns in historical context using the MSCI Equity Indices. We find that while October 2008 was, in fact, exceptionally bad, the severity depended on the market, the frequency of the returns examined, and the currency over which returns were calculated.
Publication: MSCI Barra Research Bulletins
Authors: MSCI Barra Applied Research
"Impact of Shorting Restrictions on Portfolio Efficiency", MSCI Barra Research Bulletin, October 2008
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
In this Research Bulletin, MSCI Barra presents some case studies detailing how the short selling ban on stocks of financial companies affects the construction and performance of sample pan-European equity portfolios. While these case studies do not amount to a full-scale empirical investigation, they illustrate the detrimental effects of this ban on a sample of optimal portfolios. Overall, our results suggest that the constraint on short sales of financial companies may increase the risk of the long-short portfolios and, in some cases, may decrease portfolio return. We present some evidence that this effect may be greater for 130-30 portfolios than for unconstrained long-short portfolios.
Publication: MSCI Barra Research Bulletins
Authors: MSCI Barra Applied Research
"Country & Industry Effects in Global Equities", MSCI Barra Research Bulletin, October 2008
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
This is the first in a series of Research Bulletins to mark the launch of the new and enhanced Barra Global Equity Model (GEM2). In this piece, it is shown how GEM2 may be used to track the changing importance of country and industry effects in global equity markets. This information is of use to a portfolio manager in determining the relative size of the opportunity set to generate active returns from country allocation or sector rotation. The results indicate that the relative importance of industry versus country varies across regions and over time. For instance, in emerging markets the potential to generate active returns from country allocation is significantly higher than from sector rotation, while the reverse is true in the developed world.
Publication: MSCI Barra Research Bulletins
Authors: MSCI Barra Applied Research
"Financial Leverage", MSCI Barra Research Bulletin, October 2008
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
This is the second of a series of Research Bulletins to mark the launch of the new and enhanced Barra Global Equity Model (GEM2), and its focus is on the new financial leverage factor. This factor reflects the performance of highly leveraged firms relative to firms with low leverage. The relative performance of high-leverage firms is examined under varying stock market conditions and risk environments. The leverage factor is also analyzed for any industry tilts that would result in unintended industry exposures.
Publication: MSCI Barra Research Bulletins
Authors: MSCI Barra Applied Research
"Islamic Investing in Turbulent Times", MSCI Barra Research Insight, October 2008
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
The global credit crunch has led to high levels of equity market volatility. Financial services companies have been particularly affected, with some large financial institutions failing and others seeing their market capitalization shrink rapidly. The MSCI Global Islamic Indices, however, do not contain constituents from the financial sector unless they meet the requirements in the MSCI Islamic Index Series Methodology. In this research note we examine the performance and risk characteristics of the MSCI Global Islamic Indices during the recent market turmoil.
Publication: MSCI Barra Research Insights
Authors: MSCI Barra Index Research
"Research Allocation with Return Dispersion", MSCI Barra Research Bulletin, August 2008
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
This Research Bulletin looks at an often overlooked but important challengethe allocation of resources behind investment strategies. All asset managers face the problem of how to best allocate resources, be it analysts, computational power or physical resources. Assigning more resources to segments that have more names to cover is one straightforward way. Alternatively, return dispersion (i.e., cross sectional volatility) reflects the opportunity set available to asset managers, and therefore may be another logical way. For CIOs who may consider assigning research resources via return dispersion, this article looks at the relationship between the size of different investment universes and the cross-sectional return dispersion.
Publication: MSCI Barra Research Bulletins
Authors: MSCI Barra Applied Research
"Do Risk Factors Eat Alphas?", MSCI Barra Research Insight, forthcoming in Journal of Portfolio Management
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
Portfolio managers worry that discrepancies between risk and alpha factors may create unintended biases in their optimized portfolios. We analyze the ramifications of using different factor models of risk and alpha in portfolio optimization and show that aligning risk factors with alpha factors may improve the information ratio of optimized portfolios, even if doing so lowers the overall accuracy of risk forecasts. We discuss ways of modifying a risk model that may help remedy these problems.
Publication: The Journal of Portfolio Management
Authors: LEE Jyh-Huei, STEFEK Dan
"Rate Cuts and Factor Returns", MSCI Barra Research Bulletin, March 2008
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
The bursting of the credit market bubble last year and the collapse of a major US investment bank last week resulted in a aggressive rate cutting action from 5.25% to 2.25% during the last six months, similar to the bursting of the equity market bubble in 2000 and the terrorist attacks in 2001 which prompted the Fed to cut interest rates aggressively from 6.50% to 1.75% during 2001. In this note, we examine Barra USE3S (Short term US equity risk model) factor returns' performance, volatility and correlations and identify similarities and differences across the two recent rate cutting phases.
Publication: MSCI Barra Research Bulletins
Authors: MSCI Barra Applied Research
"International Small Cap - A Distinct Asset Class?", MSCI Barra Research Insight, Oct 2007 (A version of this article appeared in the Journal of Indexes, Nov/Dec 2007)
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
The paper investigates if international small cap has been distinctly different from large caps and therefore deserved to be part of a policy benchmark. Our results indicated an increase in correlations between aggregated MSCI EAFE Small Cap and Standard Indexes in recent years. But the challenges in small cap investing have been different as the level of stock return dispersion has been larger than within the standard segment and decisions on country allocation had a bigger impact on portfolio performance within the small cap segment. We therefore conclude that an explicit allocation (or none at all) to international small cap would have provided additional diversification benefits during the period reviewed.
Publication: MSCI Barra Research Insights
Authors: NIELSEN Frank
"The Shift from Value to Growth in the U.S.", MSCI Barra Research Bulletin, October 11, 2007
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
Over the long run in the US, value stocks have outperformed growth stocks, a premium that has averaged roughly 200 basis points annually over the last four decades. Since May of this year, growth stocks have exhibited strength over value stocks, as evidenced by the MSCI USA Value and Growth Indices. In fact, the growth premium has averaged 14 percentage points annualized over the last four monthsJune, July, August, and September. In this article, we put this recent development in historical context and briefly discuss its differences from past periods and its possible drivers.
Publication: MSCI Barra Research Bulletins
Authors: MSCI Barra Applied Research
"The Shift from Value to Growth Around the World", MSCI Barra Research Bulletin, October 11, 2007
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
Over the long run globally, value stocks have outperformed growth stocks, a premium that has averaged roughly 300 basis points annually over the last four decades. Since May of this year, growth stocks have exhibited strength over value stocks, as evidenced by the MSCI World Value and Growth Indices. In fact, the growth premium has averaged 11.5 percentage points annualized over the last five monthsMay, June, July, August, and September. In this article, we put this recent development in historical context and briefly discuss its differences from past periods and its possible drivers.
Publication: MSCI Barra Research Bulletins
Authors: MSCI Barra Applied Research
"International Investing: Managing Multiple Layers of Alpha", MSCI Barra Research Insights, July 2007
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
Frequently investors have much more information than they can possibly digest. Developing and employing efficient information processing machinery to handle large amounts of data in a consistent way is the key to success in this environment. In this article we argue that it is critical for international equity asset managers to organize information according to its scope. The structure outlined here categorizes information into three types--global, local, and asset-specific. While we confine ourselves to these three types for illustration purposes, the model is readily expandable to other types of information. Other asset classes can be introduced as well.
Publication: MSCI Barra Research Insights
Authors: BENDER Jennifer, PUCHKOV Anton V
"Global Capital Markets Yearbook 2006 (Review of Benchmark Performance Across Asset Classes)",
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Multi-Asset Class
| Show/Hide Details >>
The book analyzes the performance of various asset classes using our Global Capital Markets Index, International Equity Indices, Domestic Equity Indices for the US, Japan, and China, Fixed Income Indices, and Hedge Fund Indices. This year we also have a section covering our latest efforts in the world of benchmarks, namely, the MSCI REIT indices, High Dividend Yield Indices and the GCC (Gulf Cooperation Council) Countries Indices.
Publication: MSCI Barra Yearbook
Authors: MSCI Barra
"Dynamic Volatility and its Implications for Portfolio Management", MSCI Barra Newsletter, Summer 2006
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
A discussion on the implications of changing volatility levels on active and passive portfolio management. In the Summer 2005 Horizon Newsletters, we examined the sources of cross-sectional volatility in the Japan market. We extend the study to Europe and the US market and simulate the impact of dynamically changing volatility levels on active portfolio risk. We show that the optimal level of tracking error, the size of active exposures, and the optimal number of securities vary wildly with changing volatility levels.
Publication: MSCI Barra Newsletter
Authors: NIELSEN Frank
"In Search of Global Diversification: Developed and Emerging Markets", MSCI Barra Research Insights, Spring 2006
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
Using monthly data from 1991 through 2004, we find evidence for dramatic convergence in properties of globally aggregated developed and emerging markets, greatly limiting the diversifying power of passive emerging markets investing. However, although equity returns in an 'average' emerging market follow the rest of the world more closely than a decade ago, emerging markets still constitute a dynamic and heterogeneous investment environment. We re-confirm that, given the importance of country selection, structuring the investment process along industries in a broad emerging markets universe may be premature. At the same time, there is a growing pool of emerging markets, where the importance of industry selection approaches that of country selection. Finally, we show that intra-market commonalities in equity returns offer significant diversification and return opportunities.
Publication: MSCI Barra Research Insights
Authors: NIELSEN Frank, PUCHKOV Anton V
"Declining Active Risk in Japanese Equity Portfolios", Barra Whitepaper, Spring 2005
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
Since the collapse of the Internet bubble, many Japanese portfolio managers have observed a surprising contrast between trends in tracking error and market volatility: tracking errors have fallen dramatically for many portfolios, while the volatility of the TSE1 index has declined much more gradually. The decrease in tracking error is related to a phenomenon occurring in markets around the globe. The cross-sectional dispersion of asset returns within these markets is much smaller today than it was a few years ago. The low level of cross-sectional dispersion makes the art of active portfolio management more difficult than it was before. It demands a considered response from managers.
Publication: MSCI Barra Newsletter
Authors: MILLER Guy, SENECHAL Edouard
"Long-Short Equity Investing", Barra Newsletter, Spring 2002
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
With the burst of the technology bubble and private equity returns plummeting, it is no surprise that hedge funds have become an important asset class for high net worth individuals and institutional investors alike. Recently, cautious institutions such as CalPERS, a $158 billion pension fund, and General Motors have announced their plans to allocate significant capital into this arena. Of special interest to many institutions are long-short equity strategies. In this article we will examine three popular construction techniques deployed by long-short equity portfolios: pairs trading, stratification and optimization. We will build portfolios using each of these methods and then evaluate their ability to achieve the following two goals: 1) Maximize alpha by purchasing undervalued securities and shorting overvalued securities. This has a significant advantage over long-only equity strategies by allowing a manager to better exploit overpriced securities. 2) Offer risk diversification by creating a short portfolio that reduces the long portfolio's risk. This feature enables the construction of popular 'market neutral' strategies. To evaluate the tradeoff between risk and returns, we will use the Sharpe ratio, defined as the ratio of expected returns to forecasted risk.
Publication:
Authors: CASHION Daniel, HANDA Rohtas
"The Market Impact Model (tm)", Barra Research Insights, 1999
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
In this article we will sharpen our understanding of cost modeling as we discuss the motivation behind constructing the Market Impact Model and the challenges presented by the task. We will describe the underlying economic structure of equity trading as it relates to the creation of market impact transaction costs. We apply economic reasoning and empirical data analysis to establish the framework of the calculation of a priori estimates of trading costs covering a wide range of assets and position sizes. We also discuss a wide variety of tests, from simple to complex, which may be made to explore how well the model actually works.
Publication: Research Insights
Authors: FERRARI Mark, TORRE Nicolo
"The Mechanics of Market Neutral in the Barra Aegis System(tm) Suite - Part 2", Barra Newsletter, Summer 2000
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
In the first of this series of two articles, the case was made for market neutral investing. The central arguments included double alpha, flexibility to diversify risk, an increased opportunity set and most importantly, superior information rations. Theoretical evidence, Monte Carlo simulations and empirical results all highlighted opportunities to improve performance through an institutional market neutral strategy. As the previous article suggested, long-short mangers and active, long-only managers share many similarities; their methods of portfolio construction reinforce this point. This article discusses the construction of market neutral portfolios using the new long-short optimization feature in the Aegis Portfolio Manager (tm). We also compare different long-short construction methods to demonstrate the added value of this new feature.
Publication:
Authors: LEJONVARN Jason, LEKANDER Claes
"Seven Quantitative Insights Into Active Management", Barra Research Insights, 1999
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
In past issues of Barra's newsletters, we have presented seven quantitative insights into active management. We can summarize these seven insights by observing how they all fit into the process of active management. The Research stage involves the search for superior information. This information must be better than consensus information (Insight 1: Active Management is Forecasting). We can improve our chances for success by investigating many signals (Insight 3: The Fundamental Law of Active Management). At the same time, we need to avoid data mining (Insight 5: Data Mining Is Easy). The goal of this Research stage is a strategy with a high information ratio (Insight 2: Information Ratios Determine Value Added). The Refinement stage takes our research signals and converts them to alphas by controlling for skill, volatility, and expectations (Insight 4: Three-Part Alphas). The Portfolio Construction and Rebalancing stage and the Trading stage implement the strategy. Here the goal is to lose as little of the intrinsic strategy value as possible (Insight 6: Implementation Subtracts Value). The Performance Analysis stage looks at results, identifying (imperfectly) what worked and what didn't work, in part as feedback to Research (Insight 7: It's Hard to Distinguish Skill from Luck). It is useful to note that while we have presented (and derived) these seven insights as 'quantitative,' they apply to all managers: fundamental, quantitative, top-down, bottom-up, equity, bond, and so forth. Finally, let me point out that we have called this series 'Seven Quantitative Insights...' and not 'The Seven Quantitative Insights into Active Management.' This series has omitted some known insights. And, as a researcher, I will always claim that there remain more insights to uncover. Active management combines art and engineering. The art involves finding valuable information about future returns. The engineering involves efficiently capturing that information in superior portfolios. By assuming that it is possible to find such valuable information, we can derive many important insights into the engineering of this process. Over the next several Barra Newsletters, I will outline seven insights which follow from this perspective. Richard Grinold and I discuss these points more comprehensively in our book Active Portfolio Management, and many of these items appear throughout the lore and literature of the profession.
Publication: Barra Research Insights
Authors: KAHN Ronald N.
"The Case for Market Neutral - Part 1", Barra Newsletter, Winter 1999
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
The well-publicized reversal of fortune suffered by several prominent hedge funds has moved many to fear any investment strategy that advertises the word "hedge." Not all hedge strategies deserve such a stigma. Two recent examples highlight why investors should understand the nuances of and distinctions between different hedge strategies. An article on Long-Term Capital stated, "These bets required the strategists to buy one thing and sell short another, so that they maintained a Swiss-like neutrality to the market." (1) In 1996, David Shaw pointed out that his form's proprietary strategies were "market neutral, meaning the goal is finding these little profit pockets without actually betting on the direction of the market." (2) Executives at Bank of America may to this day be asking themselves, "Was D.E. Shaw really market neutral?" This article discusses the merits of market neutral hedge strategies, particularly as they are practiced by institutional portfolio managers.
Publication:
Authors: LEJONVARN Jason, LEKANDER Claes
"Equity Program Trading", Barra Newsletter, Winter 1998
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
This article illustrates another application of Barra's Aegis System with the U.K. Equity Trading Model. The U.K. Equity Trading Model uses the latest risk-modeling techniques to help equity traders manage the short-term risk within their books, and is the first of a series of planned enhancements to Barra's risk models and applications to meet and exceed the demands of the trading community.
Publication:
Authors: BISHOPP Michael, MANANI Rakesh
"The Market Impact Model, Part 1", Barra Newsletter, Winter 1998
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
The portfolio management process benefits from timely a priori estimates of trading costs covering a wide range of assets and position sizes. Providing these estimates is the goal of the Market Impact Model. Because of econometric difficulties, a purely data-driven approach to this modeling problem cannot succeed; a combination of analytical and empirical methods is required.
Publication:
Authors: TORRE Nicolo
"The Market Impact Model, Part 4", Barra Newsletter, Fall 1998
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
In previous articles in this series, we have described the purpose of the Market Impact Model, the economic intuition behind it and the model itself. Now it is time to explore how well the model actually works. There is a wide variety of tests that may be made of the model. We shall begin with the simplest test and work up to the more complicated ones, sharpening our understanding of cost modeling as we go.
Publication:
Authors: FERRARI Mark, TORRE Nicolo
"Analyzing the Performance of Crossing Networks", Barra Newsletter, Fall 1998, pp.24-25
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
In other articles we have drawn attention to the importance of controlling transaction costs. Electronic Crossing Networks (ECNs), such as the POSIT system2, represent one approach to this problem. Participants in an ECN submit lists of orders they wish to do. The lists are matched up by a computer and matched orders are executed at the midpoint of the bid-ask spread. The system may support additional control by participants over the matching process, for instance the ability to specify minimum fill sizes. However, in this article we will focus on the bare bones of the matching process.
Publication:
Authors: LATHAM Geoff A., TORRE Nicolo
"Automating the Investment Process, The Joy of Backtesting", Barra Newsletter, Summer 1998
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
Opportunities and strategies need to be verified to gain a measure of their prospective value. One popular process for verifying an investment strategy is the backtest, which, while straightforward in theory, can often be tedious and time-consuming in practice. Since competitive advantage belongs to those who can quickly implement ideas and strategies, investment success is often a function of the underlying investment infrastructure, an idea that is explored briefly in this article.
Publication:
Authors: BOHLEN Reiner
"The Market Impact Model, Part 3", Barra Newsletter, Summer 1998
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
This is the third part of our continuing series on the Market Impact Model.(1) In the first two parts we defined the problem that the model addresses and applied economic reasoning to establish the framework of the solution. Now we shall turn to empirical data analysis to provide the details of the solution. To organize the discussion, we begin by stating the conclusion. We then begin building to this conclusion. First we treat data upon which our work rests. Next we treat each model factor in turn, surveying the principal findings of data analysis. Finally, we show how the information is assembled into the final forecast of market impact.
Publication:
Authors: TORRE Nicolo
"Allocate Capital and Measure Performances in a Financial Institution", Research Paper, 1998
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Fixed Income
| Show/Hide Details >>
This paper provides a model for allocating capital and measuring performances for financial institutions. The methodology relates the economic valuation of the balance sheet to the market value of the firm. In so doing, each business unit is evaluated on an economic basis, and the capital allocated to these units is related to the risk premiums that the market demands. The paper's results have broad applications for corporate managers, risk managers, and other market participants in managing financial institutions to increase shareholders' value.
Publication: Research Paper
Authors: HO Thomas S.Y.
"Avalanches Earthquakes and Stock Market Crashes", Barra Newsletter, Winter 1996, p15
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
One of the most important and successful concepts in finance is the stochastic process. Although stochastic processes originated from a study of Brownian motion in physics, they have since been applied to many areas in finance including options valuation, equity risk modeling, and fixed income risk modeling. Recently, another concept in physics, the theory of self-organized criticality, has generated much excitement. This theory, which has already been applied to such diverse areas as earthquakes, avalanches, the economy, and evolution, has also been proposed as a theory for understanding stock market crashes. While traditionally, these phenomena have been viewed as unrelated events, the theory of self-organized criticality had been proposed as the unifying theory that explains the nature of these seemingly unrelated phenomena. In this article, we will discuss the theory of self-organized criticality, and search for evidence of self-organized criticality in the stock market. We will also discuss the implications for money managers in the stock market.
Publication:
Authors: HUI Kenneth
"Fixed Income Active Strategies", Barra Newsletter, Fall 1996, p5
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Fixed Income
| Show/Hide Details >>
This article investigates how, conceptually, to succeed at fixed income active management. Drawing on the basic framework for active management established in "Seven Quantitative Insights Into Active Management: Insight Two" (this issue), we will discuss how to succeed at active management, and then make some empirical observations about fixed income managers. The key to active management is the information ratio. Given typical information ratios, fees and expenses, and active risk levels, net outperformance for fixed income managers is difficult. Two separate arguments--one based on active management fundamentals and one on empirical analysis of opportunities--both lead to the same conclusion: fixed income managers must use every possible opportunity to add value.
Publication:
Authors: KAHN Ronald N.
"Seven Quantitative Insights into Active Management, Part 1", Barra Newsletter, Summer 1996
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Multi-Asset Class
| Show/Hide Details >>
Active management combines art and engineering. The art involves finding valuable information about future returns. The engineering involves efficiently capturing that information in superior portfolios. By assuming that it is possible to find such valuable information, we can derive many important insights into the engineering of this process. Over the next several Barra Newsletters, seven insights that follow from this perspective will be outlined. Insight One: Active management is forecasting.
Publication:
Authors: KAHN Ronald N.
"Fixed Income", Barra Newsletter, Spring 1996
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Fixed Income
| Show/Hide Details >>
We use the Performance Attribution program of Barra's U.S. fixed ncome model to identify the sources of return to the Barra All-Government, All-Corporate, and All-MBS indices for the period December 31, 1995 April 15, 1996. In the process, we highlight significant developments in the U.S. fixed income market during the period.
Publication:
Authors: MARTIN Bill
"New Trends in International Investing", Barra Newsletter, Winter 1995, p3
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Multi-Asset Class
| Show/Hide Details >>
Investment opportunities overseas continue to attract the interest of money managers in the U.S., despite the staggering drop of equity markets in developed and emerging countries earlier this year. Portfolios that once held a few select blue chip stocks in Europe and Japan are now holding increasing portions in regions such as Southeast Asia and South America as well as in a variety of stocks within developed markets. And the current trend of overseas investment has led many index providers to enhance and expand their global indices. Barra conducted a survey of U.S. equity money managers to determine new trends in international investing. We asked 23 managers to describe their level of activity and general strategy in overseas markets. Here's what they said.
Publication:
Authors: BERTOLOTTI Andre
"Applying Style Analysis to Mutual Fund Selection", Barra Newsletter, Winter 1995, p 5
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Multi-Asset Class
| Show/Hide Details >>
Controlling for both style and volatility reveals the greatest insight to the mutual fund investor. An investor who selects mutual funds in this manner retains control over the style mix of his or her aggregate portfolio, just as the institutional plan sponsor does by blending the custom benchmarks of the managers hired. In both cases any incremental value added by the fund manager drops through to the bottom line of the aggregate portfolio. There is another important similarity between individual and institutional fund selection: in both cases identifying the winners in advance is very hard. Despite the sobering odds, this article will compare four methods of ranking mutual funds.
Publication:
Authors: DOERSCH Todd
"B2 Welcomes a New Asset Class with Open ARMS", Barra Newsletter, Fall 1995, p5
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Fixed Income
| Show/Hide Details >>
Adjustable Rate Mortgage-backed Securities (ARMS) are a large and increasingly popular segment of the U.S. bond market. On August 1, 1995, ARMS became a part of B2's database, and are now comprehensively modeled for risk and valuation analysis. The three general thrusts of this paper will be to: Give an overview of the ARMS market; Describe some of the structural properties of ARMS, and; Illustrate some of B2's functionality related to this new asset class.
Publication:
Authors: CHOI Sam
"International Minimum-Variance Strategies: Some empirical results", Barra Newsletter, Summer 1995, p1
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
Professor Robert Haugen made an astonishing observation in the early 1990s about the U.S. equity market. He stated that the return of a fully invested equity portfolio which weights the stocks to minimize total risk achieves a return that is not lower but higher than the return of the S&P 500 index.1 This portfolio has the lowest possible variance and is therefore called the minimum-variance portfolio. Investing in a minimum-variance portfolio is an appealing strategy, particularly to conservative institutional investors like pension funds and insurance companies.
Publication:
Authors: KLEEBERG Jochen M.
"Investing in ADRs", Barra Newsletter, #156 / Spring1995, p1
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
American Depositary Receipts (ADRs) offer a number of attractive features to U.S.-based global investors. They trade like U.S. stocks, so that investors avoid undependable foreign settlements, costly currency conversions, and confusing tax conventions. Also, they allow investors to buy foreign securities at current market prices, whereas country funds may sell at a premium. However, they possess all of the other problems associated with buying a foreign stock rather than a U.S. stock. Exposure to currency risk, changes in foreign tax policies, and limited financial information on the foreign company are important considerations when buying an ADR.
Publication:
Authors: BERTOLOTTI Andre, ENYEART Brian
"Valuation and Risk Analysis of International Bonds," Chapter 35 of The Handbook of Fixed Income Securities, Fourth Edition, Frank J. Fabozzi (Ed.), Business One Irwin, Homewood, IL, 1995, pp. 733-749. ",
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Fixed Income
| Show/Hide Details >>
This article presents approaches first for constructing valuation models for fixed-income securities and second for assessing the risk in portfolios of these assets. The linkages across markets in the form of currencies are also addressed in a manner which facilitates the analysis of risk by separating the local market aspects from those purely attributable to currency fluctuations.
Publication: The Handbook of Fixed Income Securities
Authors: GULRAJANI Deepak, MURPHY Brian P., WON David
"A Look at the Nikkei 300", Barra Newsletter, Winter 1994, p6
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
This article compares the NK300 to the NK225, the Tokyo Stock Exchange 1 (TSE1), and other international benchmarks such as the Financial Times (FT) Japan and the Morgan Stanley Capitalization Index (MSCI) Japan. The characteristics of the NK300 (risk and return sources) will be examined as of the end of September, 1993, and its historical performance investigated.
Publication:
Authors: ADAMS Mark, LIU Edward
"New Canadian Bond Market Index", Barra Newsletter, Winter 1994, p35
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Fixed Income
| Show/Hide Details >>
Barra, in association with RBC Dominion Securities, Inc. of Canada, released on December 6, 1993 a new Canadian fixed-income index, the DS Barra Canadian Bond Market Index. The new index provides the investment community with a benchmark that isfair, accurate and replicable and represents the investable fixed-income market in Canada. Because the constituents are known, the DS Barra Canadian Bond Market Index and sub-indices will allow portfolio managers to perform analyzes and test strategies more easily and efficiently than ever before.
Publication:
Authors: MARTIN Eric
"Tracking EAFE with Index Futures Portfolios", Barra Newsletter, Fall 1994, p1
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Derivatives
| Show/Hide Details >>
With index futures covering most of the developed country markets, can an all-index futures portfolio be used to track a global benchmark? We used the Global Equity Performance system to compare two index futures portfolios against the Morgan Stanley Capital International Europe-Australia-Far East (EAFE) index. While futures-only portfolios for tracking EAFE may have several advantages over all-stock portfolios, their recent performance raises some questions concerning their ability to track EAFE. Given that the largest difference in performance stems from differences in specific asset composition between the futures indices and their respective EAFE sub-indices (rather than industry or country mis-weightings), one might raise the question as to which list of assets is "best." Certainly, the futures-only tactic can be improved by adding stocks to the portfolio to cover more countries and to diversify the within-market position. Also, the implicit currency exposures could be hedged. By knowing the portfolio characteristics and performance, a clever manager may be able to use the advantages of index futures to improve overall portfolio performance.
Publication:
Authors: BERTOLOTTI Andre
"Alpha is Volatility Times IC Times Score", Journal of Portfolio Management, Summer 1994, pp. 9-16
This document is available in hard copy only. Please contact us to request a copy.
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Multi-Asset Class
| Show/Hide Details >>
###############################################################################################################################################################################################################################################################
Publication: Journal of Portfolio Management
Authors: GRINOLD Richard
"Are Emerging Markets too Risky for You?", Barra Newsletter, July/August 1993, p1
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
Everyone knows that investing in emerging markets is risky. That's only true, however, if you put a large proportion of your money in emerging markets. In the paper entitled "Emerging Markets: A Quantitative Perspective," we show that investment in a well-diversified emerging markets portfolio of up to 50% would have reduced the overall volatility of a global investor's portfolio over the past five years. In this article we propose a methodology to further reduce the risk of a global portfolio--through increased investments in emerging markets
Publication:
Authors: DIVECHA Arjun
"PAC IOs and PAC POs", Barra Newsletter, May/JUN 1993, p1
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Fixed Income
| Show/Hide Details >>
Interest-only planned amortization classes (PAC IOs) were touted as low-risk alternatives to top-grade corporate debt and regular Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac mortgages. However, the market for PAC Its, which one totaled $25 billion, has collapsed. The typical PAC IO has fallen 50% since late 1991 and some are even down as much as 90%. These terrible results have occurred during a bond market rally that produced positive returns of 20% on treasuries over the same period. In the last two years, the worst possible secnarieos occured for PAC IO holders. Rates fell sharply beginning in late 1991, transforming the PAC IOs from stable PACs to unstable IOs, for which the market had fallen apart. Unfortunately investors, thinking they were getting stable PAC bonds, settled for trivial spreads over regular mortgage-backeds, not understanding the huge risk they were taking. Investors undertook this risk or as little as 25 basis points over a standard Ginnie Mae mortgage. At the same time, some research papers written by Wall Street experts were touting the attractive characteristics of PAC IOs and indicating that the spreads should get even smaller. This episode illustrates the importance of analyzing CMO tranches independently using dynamic prepayment scenarios and a state-of-the-art CMO model. The behavior of a CMO tranche depends on various factors: the underlying collateral, the CMO deal structure, the position of the tranche in the deal, and the principal distribution rules, among others. Seemingly similar tranches can have very different risk-return characteristics. CMOs are complex securities. One should analyze them in a deal context using dynamic prepayment scenarios. Barra's FASTCMO program not only can enter and analyze recently issued CMO deals, it can analyze the effect of various factors that affect the risk-return performance of the tranches of existing deals.
Publication:
Authors: ANUMOLU Srinivas
"The Optimal Use of Passive Management", Barra Newsletter, March/April 1993, p6
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
Passive management is a useful tool for managing the style biases introduced by specialized active managers. For many plan sponsors, the S&P 500 is probably not the best choice for this purpose. Style index funds offer a superior alternative to the S&P 500. Choosing an appropriate amount of the total fund to put into passive vehicles and allocating among alternatives depends on the sponsor's level of risk aversion, among other things. The sponsor needs to understand the tradeoffs among the amount allocated to passive management, the style bias reduction, and the reduction in expected active return. Arbitrary constraints imposed on the allocations to individual portfolios can greatly impair the sponsor's ability to get the best possible results.
Publication:
Authors: BAKER Edward, NEWHOUSE Beth
"Risk and Return in the Canadian Bond Market, Part II", Barra Newsletter, March/April 1993, p 9
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
In the last issue of the Barra Newsletter, we described a model which values and assesses the risk of Canadian Government bonds.(1) In this article, we will describe specific models developed for the other three sectors--Provincial, Corporate, and Municipal--of the Canadian bond market. These models are then integrated with the Canadian Government bond model to produce a comprehensive Canadian valuation and risk model broadly applicable to the Canadian domestic bond market. This article builds upon the Canadian term structure model described in Part I in the previous issue of the Barra Newsletter. Together, these articles provide a complete description of our Canadian bond valuation and risk model. The yield spread models described here provide a logical and accurate description of bond spreads. The models are built upon intuitive factors to provide an integrated and comprehensive framework for analyzing value and risk in the Canadian bond market.
Publication:
Authors: CHUI Benjamin P., GULRAJANI Deepak
"Domini Social Index Performance", Barra Newsletter, November/December 1992, p8
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
| Show/Hide Details >>
The Domini Social Index (DSI) provides a broad market, common stock index for measuring the performance of portfolios with social constraints. The social investment research firm of Kinder, Lydenberg, Domini & Co. (KLD) constructs the DSI by identifying U.S. stocks that pass a multitude of common social screens, including involvement in such factors as military contracting, alcohol and tobacco, gambling, nuclear power, South African involvement, environmental mismanagement, and poor employee relations. The initial Domini Social Index was created on May 1, 1990 by KLD. We used Barra's PC Performance Analysis package (PAN) to calculate performance on the DSI index portfolios from May 1, 1990, to September 30, 1992, with the S&P 500 serving as the benchmark.
Publication:
Authors: LUCK Christopher, PILOTTE Nancy
"PACs: Are Things Always as Simple as they Look?", Barra Newsletter, November/December 1992, p1
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Fixed Income
| Show/Hide Details >>
CMOs were created to address prepayment risks inherent in a mortgage. Of the various tranches, planned amortization class (PACs) are carved out of a CMO deal in such a way so as to provide the most stability and certainty of cash flows. As a result, most investors think of PACs as straightforward tranches with minimal call and extension risk. Although most PACs are fairly secure, it is useful to be aware of the features of the deal structure that could have a significant impact on performance. In this article we will first look at the commonly used measures for predicting the behavior of PACs, namely, PAC structuring ranges and effective PSA collars. Next, we will illustrate the idea of interest rate collars as a better measure for characterizing the prepayment risks inherent in a PAC. We will then explore some features of the deal structure that affect the performance of a PAC. We will establish the need for thorough analysis within the context of the whole deal, for even straightforward tranches like PACs, to account for tranche interdependencies in complex deals.
Publication:
Authors: BHANSALI Roveen
"The Contingent Claims Arms Race", Barra Newsletter, July/August 1992, p1
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Derivatives
| Show/Hide Details >>
Although the cold war is over, "rocket" scientists are hard at work extending and elaborating fixed income contingent claims models for evaluating embedded options. While option-modeling technology has become very advanced and useful, a body of cant, which can befuddle the unsuspecting practitioner, also surrounds it. In this article, three observations are explored: volatility is the most important model parameter; even bad models can be tuned to give good results for the most simple options, and; good models are good because they work over a wider range of options.
Publication:
Authors: LOCHOFF Roland
"New S&P/Barra 'Style' Indices", Barra Newsletter, May/June 1992, p15
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Multi-Asset Class
| Show/Hide Details >>
Barra, in collaboration with Standard and Poor's Corporation, has constructed the S&P/Barra Growth Index and S&P/Barra Value Index to separate the S&P 500 into value stocks and growth stocks. The design of the indexes is an outgrowth of research into investment styles in the U.S. equity market performed in conjunction with 1990 Nobel Laureate William F. Sharpe. The indexes serve as benchmarks for institutional investors who wish to more closely track these two dominant investment styles in the market.
Publication:
Authors: BUCKLEY Oliver
"Barra Institutional Style Indices", Barra Newsletter, November/December 1991, p3
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Multi-Asset Class
| Show/Hide Details >>
Barra has traditionally seen the market place as multifaceted, and we have captured those facets of the market through factors such as SIZE, VOLATILITY, SUCCESS, VALUE, GROWTH, and the like. The opposite viewpoint is the old, one-dimensional separation of stocks into large and small. Style indices represent something of a midpoint between Barra's multifaceted view of the market and the one-dimensional view. To create style indices we look along the axis of value and growth and end up with a matrix stratification into categories such as large-value, large-growth, small-value, small-growth, and so on. Style indices are similar to factors in that it is possible to define a style portfolio as a list of stock holdings. Style index portfolios have the added benefit of being a capitalization-weighted list of assets; that is, the critical item in the style portfolio is membership in the list; weighting is always in proportion to capitalization. Every asset in the market gets included in only one of the style portfolios, so we can consider the style portfolios as pieces of a mosaic; put all the pieces together and you get the market.!
Publication:
Authors: DIVECHA Arjun, GRINOLD Richard
"Battle of the Bonds: Intermediate vs. Long", Barra Newsletter, November/December 1991, p10
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Fixed Income
| Show/Hide Details >>
What is the appropriate passive benchmark or target for the fixed income portion of a pension fund? Long bonds don't seem to reward investors for the additional 'horizon' risk. Long bonds are an appropriate investment only when rates are expected to decline. The appropriate neutral position is to invest in intermediates; thus, the target portfolio or long-term benchmark should be intermediate, not long, bonds.
Publication:
Authors: BAKER Edward
"Changes in the Nikkei 225", Barra Newsletter, September/October1991, p4
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
On October 1, 1991, six companies in the Nikkei 225 were replaced. A change in a widely-followed index has implications for both active and passive investors. Passive investors must make trades to keep up with the new index. Active investors for whom the index serves as a benchmark find that an already-moving "target" has suddenly jumped out of their sights. In this report, we'll look at how different the old index is from the new and whether the new index represents any structural shifts in the market. We'll also see how the index has changed along different dimensions, industries, and risk characteristics, and compare the tracking error of the new index to the old one.
Publication:
Authors: DIVECHA Arjun
"Using Floating Rate Notes to Control Risk and Return", Barra Newsletter, September/October 1991, p13
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Fixed Income
| Show/Hide Details >>
Floating rate notes, or "floaters," are bonds whose coupon is tied to a prevailing interest rate, such as the six-month T-bill rate. Since their coupon is not fixed, they offer investors a unique tool to control risk and return In particular, floaters offer a long stream of cash flows with low duration (term structure risk exposure). Many, such as mortgage-backed floaters, offer a higher yield than a comparable short-term security while maintaining high quality. Finally, floaters allow an investor to take on active spread bets while taking on little or no term structure risk. To benefit from these attributes, an investor must understand the nature of floaters from their simple form (the default-free floater) to the more complex (floaters with a corporate spread).
Publication:
Authors: MITROFF Andrea
"Factor Tilting", Barra Newsletter, July/August 1991, p1
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
Many of our clients have begun to use factor tilts as an active investment strategy. This relatively lowrisk strategy emphasizes or deemphasizes those factors which the manager thinks will outperform or underperform the market.. We hope the following discussion will help readers formulate tilt strategies, and will help current tilt managers more explicitly consider some potential pitfalls.
Publication:
Authors: LUCK Christopher
"Market Segmentation and the New York Stock Exchange", Barra Newsletter, July/August 1991, p14
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
A variety of off-exchange trading alternatives have sprung up in the last five years. The most widely used are POSIT and Instinet. Off-exchange trading may well erode the NYSE's market share. But are the new trading systems bad for market participants? We obviously don't think so. POSIT fills a market niche by facilitating confidential portfolio trading, and it is especially popular with passive and quantitative portfolio managers.
Publication:
Authors: BAKER Edward
"New Zealand's Index Funds", Barra Newsletter, March/April 1991, p1
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
How difficult is it to track a market index with a limited number of assets? The question is an important one, since most of the world's smaller equity markets are narrow and are dominated by a few large companies. This type of structure has definite consequences in predicting the risk of portfolios holding these countries' assets. New Zealand is a case in point. Its market is quite narrow; its largest company, Fletcher Challenge, represents more than 23% of the Barclays Index, and its five largest companies make up 64% of the weight of the forty-stock capitalization-weighted index. How well can we track the Barclays Index - New Zealand's most quoted? The compromise between a portfolio which reduces tracking error and one which is easy to implement is an individual decision to be made by each investor. The investor may find the Global Equity Model useful in informing this decision, whether in New Zealand's equity market or in other small markets.
Publication:
Authors: HARRISON Andrew
"SMALLCAP Indices Without Tears", Barra Newsletter, March/April 1991, p6
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
Indices play an important role in portfolio management. Beyond measuring economic growth, they can also serve as manager performance benchmarks and can be used to define manager style. But turnover can reduce some indices' suitability as benchmarks. This is particularly true for small-capitalization stock indices, which are prone to high turnover. Why do small capitalization stock indices experience high turnover, and is there an approach which will reduce this turnover while preserving the indices investment character?
Publication:
Authors: BECKERS Stan, CUMMINS Paul, WOODS Chris
"Value Added & Tactical Asset Allocation", Barra Newsletter, January/February 1991, p6
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Multi-Asset Class
| Show/Hide Details >>
A proponent of tactical asset allocation claims that a good tactical asset allocator is more valuable than an equally good equity or bond manager. After all, the tactical asset allocator influences more assets. This assertion raises two interesting questions. What do we mean when we say an allocator or a manager is "good?" And how is value added related to assets under management? (Or, if we want to reverse causality, "How should assets under management be related to the ability to add value?")
Publication:
Authors: GRINOLD Richard
"The Earth Trembled, but the Street Held Firm," Barra Newsletter, October 1990, p1. ",
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
Predictions of economic disaster for the San Francisco Bay Area followed close upon the heels of last year's Loma Prieta earthquake. Businesses would be hobbled by transportation bottlenecks, loss of plant and equipment, and a stunned labor force. Sensational media coverage of the destruction in Santa Cruz, the fire in San Francisco, and the demolished Cypress Street freeway structure in Oakland only reinforced this bleak prognosis. Many expected Wall Street to rush out even as the Red Cross, Dan Quayle and Dan Rather rushed in. Barra's analysis shows otherwise. The stocks of locally based firms actually outperformed a comparable national index in the last year. The relatively strong performance of the Bay Area portfolio is a pleasant suprise. Those looking for evidence of event risk in the equity market won't find much here. Investors who resisted a knee-jerk reaction to dump Bay Area stocks after the earthquake were rewarded for their fortitude.
Publication:
Authors: FREEMAN John
"The Quantitative Approach to Trading: An Example", Barra Newsletter, August/September 1990, p1
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Equities
| Show/Hide Details >>
Consider the trading process at its most basic. You have cash and you want to buy a stock. You think the stock will go up. You want to buy soon, before the stock rises. But to avoid market impact, you are willing to be patient and assume some risk of missing the stock rise. What is your optimal trading strategy? Every day, portfolio managers face these decisions: portfolio construction, portfolio rebal-ancing, trading to achieve excess returns net of transaction costs. In the portfolio context, the number of stocks increases but the issues are the same. The manager wants to transact before anticipated price moves, yet wishes to minimize transaction costs. This article will illustrate a quantitative approach to determining an optimal trading strategy, using the particular and simple example of buying a single stock
Publication:
Authors: KAHN Ronald N.
"A Barra View of Active (Fixed Income) Management--Part 4", Barra Newsletter, September 1989, p10
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Fixed Income
| Show/Hide Details >>
In our May, June, and August (1989) Newsletters (see "A Barra View of Active Management: Parts 1, 2 and 3", U.S. Newsletters # 117/ 188, 120), we explored some aspects of active management. We looked at utility as the measure of an active portfolio. This concept can be applied to managers who use quantitative techniques for developing their insights and those that use more qualitative approaches. Either way, maximizing portfolio utility makes good use of manager insights, while avoiding unnecessary risk. These recent articles used U.S. equity management examples. This paper explores how these ideas make sense in a fixed income context.
Publication:
Authors: FEINSTEIN Allan
"A Barra View of Active Management--Part 3", Barra Newsletter, August 1989, p1
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Fixed Income
| Show/Hide Details >>
In Parts 1 and 2 of this series [See the May 1989 (#117) and June 1989 (#118) Barra U.S. Newsletters] we talked about active management from the perspective of a highly quantitative manager and from the viewpoint of a more qualitative manager. Both managers concentrated on asset selection. That is, they each had a method of selecting assets that they thought would experience extraordinary return. Any common factor positions that resulted were purely incidental to their processes. We used the Optimizer to reduce these common factor positions, while maintaining a tilt toward assets they preferred. This month, we will consider a manager with a factor tilt strategy. This manager has been hired to manage U.S. equity funds which outperform the S&P500. The manager has looked at the history of the Barra factors and has decided to tilt the portfolio toward risk indexes that have performed well in the past.
Publication:
Authors: FEINSTEIN Allan
"A Barra View of Active Management --Part 2", Barra Newsletter, June 1989, p1
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Fixed Income
| Show/Hide Details >>
In the May 1989 Barra U.S. Newsletter ("A Barra View of Active Management"), we began a series on active management by talking about utility as the key concept in Barra's approach to this management style. We took as an example a highly quantitative manager using a dividend discount model as their sole source of active management information. This month, we use a completely different manager style as an example. This month's manager does not quantify judgements in terms of expected returns. We consider this manager to be non-quantitative in the sense that their judgements are expressed in a non-quantitative fashion. Will a manager with a non-quantitative way of expressing their views be able to build improved portfolios by increasing utility?
Publication:
Authors: Source: Barra Newsletter
"Confessions of a Pool Player: Humility and Active Management", Barra Newsletter, December 1989/January 1990, p 5
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Multi-Asset Class
| Show/Hide Details >>
The ingredients needed for successful active management are luck, skill, and humility. Luck and skill are obviously valuable. Humility, as in knowing what you don't know, is required when luck fails. This article shows how humility can work to your advantage. Humility places the burden of proof on the active decision. It forces the manager first to decide what portfolio to hold when he or she has no insights, and then to justify deviations from that original portfolio due to his or her particular insights. Deviations need to be justified with expectations of compensating return, and a method of portfolio construction should be used to make sure that the highest level of expected return is attained per unit of risk.
Publication:
Authors: Source: Barra Newsletter
"Uses and Abuses of Convexity", Barra Newsletter, November 1988, p3
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Fixed Income
| Show/Hide Details >>
A popular technique in the fixed income world is linking the percentage price change of a bond (for a given change in yield) to the bond's duration and convexity. This technique makes use of a Taylor series expansion and the idea that duration and convexity are variants of the first and second derivatives of the valuation equation. Much has been made elsewhere of the drawbacks of using duration and convexity as the only measures of a bond's risk, or even as measures of the bond's interest rate risk. This article explores the paradoxes that arise in modelling optionable bonds and the representation of price changes through a Taylor series expansion.
Publication:
Authors: Source: Barra Newsletter
"Report from the Seventh Fixed Income Seminar, Part V: Bond/Equity Market Linkages", Barra Newsletter, May 1988, p5
Topic: Investing (Investment Management) |
Asset Class: Fixed Income
| Show/Hide Details >>
Barra's annual Fixed Income Seminar took place in October 1987, one week before the infamous stock market crash of October 19. At that time we noted an extremely rare event that had already occurred in the year's financial markets. For the first time in recent history, fixed income and equity returns were not only moving in different directions, but were correlated at an unprecedented - .44.(1) Historically, of course, changes in interest rates have had parallel, driving effects on both the bond and stock markets. Prompted in part by the surprising events of 1987, we decided to take a closer look not only at the links between the stock and bond markets as a whole, but also at connections between common factors in these markets.
Publication:
Authors: Source: Barra Newsletter